HomeHealth articlespaleo dietPaleo vs. Keto Diets: Which Is Best for Me?

Paleo vs. Keto Diets: Which Is Best for Me?

Verified dataVerified data
0
Paleo vs. Keto Diets: Which Is Best for Me?

4 min read

Share

The paleo diet focuses on natural foods similar to those consumed by early humans, while the keto diet aims to minimize carbohydrate intake.

Medically reviewed by

Dr. K. Shobana

Published At June 20, 2018
Reviewed AtMarch 28, 2024

Introduction

Health-conscious individuals start looking for various exercises and diet plans that help to keep them healthy and fit. Diet has an important place in overall well-being, and modern science has many diet plans that can be customized to individual needs. Among them, two popular diet plans are paleo and keto. Although they are confusingly similar, they are not the same. The article briefly introduces the ideologies of each of these diets.

What Is a Paleo Diet?

The paleo diet is short for a paleolithic diet, which denotes eating natural foods that ancestors would have eaten. Since modern-age diseases stem from eating too much processed, man-made food with too much salt and preservatives, these are the very things that are to be avoided on a paleo diet.

What Is the Purpose of the Paleo Diet?

The main purpose of a paleo diet is to take food likely eaten by early humans. The diet is mainly based on the fact that the genes of the present human cannot adjust to modern diets. Farming made food easily available, and it also introduced dairy. Farming also altered the diets of the animals that people eat. The idea of the paleo diet is that alteration in the diet outpaced the ability of the human body to change. This contributes to obesity, diabetes, etc.

What Is a Keto Diet?

The keto diet is short for the ketogenic diet. It was a diet initially created to prevent seizures in those with epilepsy. There were reduced incidences of seizures when patients with epilepsy went on fasting periods. In a keto diet, the body goes into ketosis (the result of burning fat for fuel) when carbohydrates are reduced. So, here, the focus is on eating a low-carb, high-fat diet, which teaches the body to burn fat instead of glucose. It is now used more as a weight loss tool and is widely accepted across the globe because of its promising results, even within a short period.

What Foods Are Included and Excluded in a Paleo Diet?

Foods to Include:

  • Consume fruits, vegetables, eggs, meat, seafood, tubers, fats, nuts, roots, shoots, and seeds.

  • The focus is on natural, unprocessed foods, mirroring the diet of Paleolithic ancestors.

Foods to Exclude:

  • Eliminate difficult-to-digest foods like cereals, legumes, grains, beans, soy, and dairy products.

  • Remove refined oil, sugar, excessive salt, bread, and processed foods.

Benefits:

What Foods Are Included and Excluded in a Keto Diet?

  • The keto diet focuses on specific macronutrient ratios and restricts high-carb foods more than the paleo diet. Additionally, keto includes dairy as a source of healthy fats.

  • In the keto diet, strict attention is given to macronutrient ratios in meals, with recommended proportions of 70 to 80 percent fats, 20 to 25 percent protein, and five to 10 percent carbohydrates.

  • Unlike the paleo diet, keto restricts several high-carb foods, including:

  • Starchy vegetables (for example - sweet potatoes, pumpkin, carrots, yams, and squash)

  • High-carb fruits (for example - bananas, pineapples, and grapes)

  • Natural sweeteners (for example - honey, maple syrup)

  • Dried fruits (for example - raisins, dates)

What Are the Pros and Cons of the Paleo Diet?

Pros:

  • Simplified Eating: Unlike some diets, this diet plan does not need to meticulously track macronutrient percentages (fats, proteins, and carbs), making it easier to follow.

  • Lifestyle Change: Paleo is more than just a diet; it promotes a broader lifestyle shift by eliminating unhealthy food types and fostering long-term well-being.

  • Nutrient-Rich Foods: Focusing on whole, natural foods leads to a diet rich in essential nutrients and eliminating processed, unhealthy options.

Cons:

  • Potential Overindulgence: The absence of strict macronutrient guidelines may lead to overconsumption of carb-rich sources, like fruits.

  • Limited Weight Loss: While it can contribute to weight loss, especially when carb intake is restricted, it may not be the most effective solution for rapid weight loss.

  • Gradual Weight Loss: Any weight loss on the Paleo diet is typically gradual rather than rapid.

What Are the Pros and Cons of the Keto Diet?

Pros:

  • Effective for Weight Loss: The keto diet is known for its significant and rapid weight loss results, making it a popular choice for those seeking to shed pounds.

  • Measurable Progress: Ketone levels can be regularly measured to ensure a state of ketosis, helping to track and stay on course.

  • Health Benefits: Ketosis, achieved by reducing carb intake, offers various health benefits, including lowered blood pressure, improved blood sugar control, weight loss, better cholesterol levels, and enhanced mental clarity.

Cons:

  • Restrictive Nature: The keto diet is highly restrictive, which can be challenging to incorporate into a busy daily routine.

  • Carb Reduction: Those accustomed to a high-carb diet will face a drastic change, limiting carb intake to just five percent.

Which Diet Is Healthier?

  • Both paleo and keto diets can be healthy if used correctly, but in a direct comparison, the paleo diet tends to be a healthier choice for most people.

  • The paleo diet offers more flexibility in food choices and provides various options to ensure an individual gets the necessary nutrients daily. It promotes an overall healthy lifestyle.

  • The paleo diet is easier to maintain long-term and is less likely to isolate socially due to its food options.

  • While the keto diet has its merits and can benefit specific health conditions, it is not suitable for everyone. It requires strict compliance to achieve ketosis, which can be challenging. Additionally, consuming too much saturated fat on a high-fat diet like keto may increase the risk of heart disease.

  • Keto's limited flexibility can also make obtaining all the essential nutrients the body needs difficult.

Conclusion

While the paleo diet does not strictly limit carbs, it is essential to avoid excessive carb intake as it can interfere with dietary goals and metabolism. It is a good idea to keep carb consumption in check to get the most out of a paleo lifestyle. A balanced approach that combines elements of both keto (carefully tracking macros and reducing carbs) and paleo (eating natural, nutrient-rich foods) can be a great way to improve health. Remember that the best diet varies from person to person, so consider health, budget, and practicality when choosing the right one.

Frequently Asked Questions

1.

Is Keto or Paleo Diet Better for Weight Loss?

According to research comparing the keto vs. paleo diets for weight loss, both diets can be successful. Although the low-carb eating plans resemble one another, the keto and paleo diets have very different advantages and side effects. However, the keto diet is very effective in quickly losing weight.

2.

Is the Paleo Diet the Healthiest Option?

Researchers discovered that lower risk factors for cardiovascular disease or heart disease were associated with the paleo diet. The lower risk was primarily due to eating more fruits and vegetables and avoiding highly processed foods like chips and candy. The increased consumption of protein from animal food sources in the paleo diet results in a high intake of saturated fats, which is detrimental to overall health. Dieters may experience an increase in cholesterol over time, especially the less beneficial cholesterol. This might make heart disease more likely.

3.

Is the Keto or Paleo Diet Better for Inflammation?

It would be better to try paleo if you wanted to fight inflammation and autoimmune diseases. However, you should choose keto if attempting to manage PCOS (polycystic ovarian syndrome), diabetes, or metabolic syndrome. However, if losing extra fat is the goal, paleo and keto are almost equally effective.

4.

Is Paleo a More Sustainable Diet Than Keto?

Fruit and starchy vegetables are included in the paleo diet, but the keto diet does not because they are too high in carbohydrates. Fifty grams of carbohydrates or less per day constitute a true keto diet. As a result, paleo is better for both physical performance and overall digestive health. Also, compared to the keto diet, it is a more sustainable eating strategy.

5.

Which Diet Is the Healthiest for People?

The three best diets currently are still the Mediterranean diet, the DASH (dietary approaches to stop hypertension)  diet, and the flexitarian diet. Doctors also strongly advise all three diets due to their known health advantages. Since there are no set calorie limits or portion sizes for the Mediterranean diet, it can be adapted to almost anyone's needs.

6.

What Are the Negative Effects of the Paleo Diet?

People not used to eating high-fiber paleo-friendly foods like fruits, vegetables, nuts, and seeds may experience diarrhea following higher-fiber diets, such as in well-planned paleo diets. Constipation may occur if the paleo diet is low in fiber-rich foods, such as fruits, vegetables, nuts, and other paleo-friendly sources of fiber. Long-term use of the paleo diet may harm gut health by lowering the proportion of helpful bacteria and raising the proportion of Hungatella bacteria that produce TMA (the metabolite trimethylamine). In addition, a lack of sufficient calories or carbohydrates in a poorly planned paleo diet may have a negative impact on energy levels.

7.

Who Should Avoid the Keto Diet?

Not everyone should follow a ketogenic diet. People with kidney damage, those at risk for heart disease, pregnant or nursing women, those with type 1 diabetes, those with pre-existing liver or pancreatic conditions, and anyone who has had their gallbladder removed should not attempt the keto diet.

8.

Can You Combine Paleo and Keto Diets?

Combining a ketogenic diet with some of the core tenets of the paleo diet can reap the benefits of both ketosis and paleo eating. You can achieve this by abstaining from all foods that are not paleo-friendly and adhering to the keto macronutrient ratios (carbohydrates, fats, and protein).

9.

How Does Switching to a Paleo Diet Affect Your Body?

Short-term benefits of the paleo diet include aiding in weight loss, lowering blood pressure, and controlling blood sugar, but long-term risks include nutrient deficiencies and other potential health risks, according to experts. For example, according to studies, some people who follow a paleo diet plan may experience diarrhea, constipation, fatigue, and changes in their gut flora.

10.

What Are the Cardiologists’ Opinions on the Keto Diet?

The diet reduces triglycerides, a blood fat type that, at high levels, raises the risk of pancreatitis, heart disease, and stroke. In addition, the ketogenic diet is linked to higher levels of HDL, the "good cholesterol" lipoprotein that lowers the risk of heart disease. Overall, ketogenic diets seem secure and may assist in controlling the risk factors that affect heart health.

11.

How Long Does It Take To See Paleo Diet Results?

Most people who switch to a paleo diet will notice that they lose weight quickly and significantly. One should expect to lose between five and ten pounds in the first week, which is a sizable amount. Following that, the weight loss will be gradual rather than drastic.

12.

What Are the Adverse Effects of the Keto Diet?

Constipation and nutrient deficiencies can result from eliminating whole grains, beans, fruits, and many vegetables. An upset stomach, also known as the "keto flu," fatigue, headaches, and brain fog are typical short-term side effects. In addition, kidney stones, liver disease, and osteoporosis are long-term health risks.
Source Article IclonSourcesSource Article Arrow
Dr. Vasantha. K. S
Dr. Vasantha. K. S

Dentistry

Tags:

paleo diet
Community Banner Mobile
By subscribing, I agree to iCliniq's Terms & Privacy Policy.

Source Article ArrowMost popular articles

Do you have a question on

paleo diet

Ask a doctor online

*guaranteed answer within 4 hours

Disclaimer: No content published on this website is intended to be a substitute for professional medical diagnosis, advice or treatment by a trained physician. Seek advice from your physician or other qualified healthcare providers with questions you may have regarding your symptoms and medical condition for a complete medical diagnosis. Do not delay or disregard seeking professional medical advice because of something you have read on this website. Read our Editorial Process to know how we create content for health articles and queries.

This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. iCliniq privacy policy