Q. Would you recommend pranayama for a 90 year old?

Answered by Dr. Vinod Kumar and medically reviewed by iCliniq medical review team.

 

New
Do you have a question on Pranayama or Enhance Breathing? We have medical experts to help you right away. Ask a Doctor Now »
 

Hi doctor,

My father is 90 years old. He has congestive heart failure and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. He is generally in good spirits and is well taken care of. He uses oxygen and his doctors have told him that when his oxygen count goes down, to breathe in and exhale through mouth. Since his breathing is generally weak, after every time he walks or climbs stairs, he sits down with this oxygen tank and breathes in slightly and then exhales, usually with more force than he inhaled. I am trying to teach my mother about pranayama and the importance of exhaling through the nose. Her concern is that the doctors have taught them the breath in through nose technique and exhale through the mouth. Given that he is 90 with those conditions, on oxygen, is there a reason that he should use the technique the doctors are recommending? Would it be more beneficial to breath in through the nose and exhales slowing through the nose, even with the tubes in his nose? The latter makes more sense to me but since my mother only trusts her doctors, she asked to get more information about this. Thank you so much for your time.


Related Questions:
I have pain in ribs and breathing problems. Is it a sign of lung cancer?
I am constantly aware of my breathing and try to control it. Please help me.
Smoking, an Illness and Not Just a Habit
 

Dr. Vinod Kumar
BAMS., MD (YOGA & REHABILITATION
Yoga

Hi,

Welcome to icliniq.com.

Thanks for posing this question. Please find my suggestions below.

At age 90, it becomes very important to keep the things simple for the patient. Your effort to teach pranayama is appreciable.

I would advise you not to go for any difficult pranayama which is tedious to understand. Nadi suddhi and anuloma viloma or alternate nostril breathing is sometimes confusing for elderly people.

  • Something very simple like abdominal breathing or just deep breathing can be useful. This can be done in sitting or in the lying posture also.
  • Introduce it in lying first and then plan it in sitting with support. Finally, we can also think of it being done in sitting without support with back erect.

If the above option is also found to be difficult, then just ask him to follow breath awareness, where one just needs to focus on breath without any active effort for its manipulation either sitting or lying.

  • All fast breathing practices will be considered as contraindicated. For example kapalbhati, bhastrika and mukha dhouti. Very slow kapalbhati can be initiated under strict medical supervision under guidance of a trained yoga therapist and not yoga teacher.
  • Any breathing practice where inhalation is suggested through the mouth is contraindicated. Inhaling through mouth increase risk of respiratory infections. It is even more risky for patients with congestive heart failure and COPD (chronic obstructive pulmonary disease), as in your case. So, all cooling pranayama (sitali, sitkari and sadanta) are to be avoided.

Exhaling through the mouth is perfectly fine as far as the patient is comfortable. But, there is nothing wrong in exhaling through the nose also. Let it be decided by the patient whether he wants to exhale through the mouth or through the nose.

Both ways of exhaling seems to be equally good with a bit extra priority to exhaling through the mouth. Let us not trouble him by putting any unnecessary rules.

I will consider bhramari pranayama (chanting of Nnnn while exhaling) to be best for him.

  • Chanting or nada-anusandhana can be especially good for him, but definitely without any unnecessary stress on prolonged exhalation as is usually suggested by yoga Instructors. Some examples of chanting will be Om chanting, Aaa chanting, Uuu chanting and Mmm chanting.

If any religious concerns are there about any of the chanting, then these can be replaced with either only bhramari pranayama or instead of Om some other words like swim can be followed with emphasis on ''Mmmm'' sound and very minimal ''swi'' sound. Any other similar words or chants can be chosen.

  • Singing is something generally beneficial for such patients. Follow his interest and let him try something.
  • Graded physical exercise under supervision should be encouraged and need to be a part of the routine.
  • I will put practices in order of preference here: Chanting and bhramari, breathe awareness and slow breathing practices.
  • Retention of air in the lungs is common in respiratory disorders, so prolonged exhalation is common advise.
  • At any stage, if there is a sudden worsening of breathlessness with or without pranayama practice, then contact your nearby hospital immediately.

Treatment proposed here is to be followed under supervision and several modifications or omissions and replacements may be needed for different individuals with same ailment or same individual at different stages of ailment.

For further information consult a yoga specialist online --> https://www.icliniq.com/ask-a-doctor-online/yoga-specialist

 
 
Ask your health query to a doctor online?
 
Ask a Doctor Online »
* guaranteed answer within 4 hours.

Related Questions & Answers


Why do I wake after sleeping with high heart rate and breathing problems?
Query: Hello doctor, I nearly wake up every night two to three hours after I go to bed. Symptoms are high heart rate (150 to 170) and breathing problems. My heart has been diagnosed and today I got an X-ray of my lung. What I think is strange. I only wake up, when I lie on my right side. I never woke up w...  Read Full »
Dr. Vivek Chail
General Practitioner

Answer: Hi, Welcome to icliniq.com. I have viewed your X-ray images (attachment removed to protect patient identity). X-ray chest PA view and X-ray chest lateral view. The lung markings are mildly prominent and it can be a normal finding in many individuals and some people with hyperactive airways due to ...  Read Full »
 
Please suggest yoga asanas that would improve blood flow to testicles.
Query: Hi doctor, Please suggest me the yoga names to improve blood flow to the testicles. I have weak erections, watery semen, and loss of libido. I am taking Pantogem DSR for indigestion and Stalopam plus for stress. My local doctor prescribed these medicines.  Read Full »
Dr. Shakti Mishra
Nutritionist

Answer: Hello, Welcome to icliniq.com. Continue with the prescribed medication. Along with that meditation, exercises, and yoga can help improve your condition. Deep breathing, inhalation through nose and exhalation through the mouth, improves blood circulation. Suryanamaskar is the most efficient form ...  Read Full »
 
How does yoga help senior citizens?
Query: Hi doctor, What are the health benefits and trends for yoga for senior citizens? Are there studios that have classes or professionals that cater to this demographic? Why choose yoga over other forms of fitness and stretching?  Read Full »
Dr. Vinod Kumar Goyal
Ayurveda Specialist

Answer: Hi, Welcome to icliniq.com. Yoga is of two types. One for physical exercises called asanas and the second one is meditational yoga. Both have tremendous benefits for life and health. Physical yoga regulates body glands, hormones and cures many diseases of the body. For different persons and condit...  Read Full »
 
 

Ask your health query to a doctor online?
 
Ask a Doctor Online »
* guaranteed answer within 4 hours.
 

Ask a Doctor Online

* guaranteed answer within 4 hours
 

Most Viewed


Can transvaginal scan cause spotting during pregnancy?
Hi doctor, I have a history of recurrent early miscarriage (before seven weeks). Investigations pointed to high autoimm ...Read more »
My hairline has reduced. Should I opt for Ayurveda, homeopathy, or other alternative medicine?
Hello doctor, I am a 40-year-old male. For past five to six years my hairline has reduced drastically, a kind of patter ...Read more »
How to Grow Thick and Dark Eyelashes - Uses | Work | Effective | Precautions | Side Effects
Women use mascaras, artificial eyelashes, and a lot of other cosmetic products to make their eyelashes look long, thick, ...Read more »