Cancer

Challenges of Patient Counseling in India

Written by
Dr. Jatin Bhatia
and medically reviewed by Dr. Sneha Kannan

Published on Apr 19, 2019   -  2 min read

Abstract

Abstract

Patient counseling is an art, which every doctor should be skilled at. Every patient is different and the art of convincing the patient to take the right treatment is a challenge which depends upon multiple factors.

Challenges of Patient Counseling in India

Patient counseling is an art, which every doctor should be skilled at. Every patient is different, and the art of convincing the patient to take the right treatment is a challenge which depends upon multiple factors. Dynamics of patient counseling in our country differ significantly from the west. In the west, patient forms the most important aspect of clinical decision making, his or her right to be informed cannot be violated unless he or she is not medically fit to take decisions.

Despite the same principles being available on paper, they are seldom practiced here. In India, everybody is a decision maker, citing the reason that they know what is best for the patient. This role is taken usually by the doctor or the primary health care doctor or the relative who accompanies the patient to the clinic, or it could be a distant relative sitting abroad who may or may not have the required medical knowledge.

There are multiple well-researched guidelines for most of the cancers at a national and international level. Patient counseling is not only about mentioning the prognosis, discussing treatment options, and associated side effects, but expressing them in a manner that makes the patient and all accompanying members comfortable and convinced. The most important principle of counseling is convincing them that what you are saying is right. This sometimes implies hiding vital information from the patient on a special request or sometimes from the relatives. There are so many patients completing treatment without even being aware of their disease, prognosis, treatment risks, and benefits, only because of one relative who feels that it is best for the patient. Interestingly, this usually works, either the patient gets better, and the truth has less impact or the patient succumbs to the treatment or disease and the truth hardly matters.

Gaining faith of the patients and their relatives in such a scenario becomes more important than keeping them informed. Sometimes, the simplest of treatment decisions are not so simple or obvious from the patient or relative’s perspective. People believe what they want to believe, and this drives many patients towards second and sometimes third opinions. In this chain, it gets difficult for the doctors to get the right advice implemented. If a surgeon recommends against surgery, the perception is that the doctor might not be good, so let us take a second opinion from a better surgeon, who might not be a surgeon, to begin with. Amid mistrust and the concept that one doctor is better than another, we sometimes fail to do what is right.

Last reviewed at:
19 Apr 2019  -  2 min read

RATING

18
Ask a QueryAsk a Query Consult by PhoneConsult by Phone Video ChatVideo Chat

Tags:

Comprehensive Medical Second Opinion.Submit your Case

Related Questions & Answers


Cancerous Conditions Related to the Eye

Article Overview: Cancer is a leading cause of mortality and morbidity in the developed world and is on the rise among all age groups and social strata. The eye is also not spared from cancerous afflictions and has a whole plethora of cancerous and precancerous conditions that require proper evaluation and care by ophthalmologists. This article looks at the main cancers of the eye and has been written to be a basic guide to the common man about what important symptoms s/he will need to be concerned about and those problems that would need an immediate consultation with an ophthalmologist. Read Article


Dr. Manjunath Natarajan
Eye Care Ophthalmologist

Cancer is a leading cause of mortality and morbidity in the developed world and is on the rise amongst all age groups and social strata. The eye is also not spared from cancerous afflictions and has a whole plethora of cancerous and precancerous conditions that require proper evaluation and care by ...  Read Article

My sister's report shows 46, XY chromosome. What does this mean?

Query: Hi doctor, My sister is 18 years old, and she has never had periods. Recently, we did a test which said, 46, XY (20), 20 cells were counted, all cells showed 46 chromosomes. Small chromosomal anomalies and small clonal population may not be detected using the standard methods employed. Could you pl...  Read Full »

Cervical Cancer - Causes and Prevention

Article Overview: Estimates suggest that by 2025 more than 365 women will die due to cervical cancer everyday. Cervical cancer is caused by HPV (Human Papilloma Virus ) and mainly affects young women. Read Article


Dr. Kamalpreet Kaur Nagpal
Obstetrician And Gynaecologist

Trivia: Estimates suggest that by 2025 more than 365 women will die due to cervical cancer every day. Cervical cancer is the second largest cancer affecting women's health. What Causes Cervical Cancer? Cervical cancer is caused by HPV (Human Papilloma Virus ) and mainly affects young women. ...  Read Article

Popular Articles Most Popular Articles

Do you have a question on Cancer or Treatment Of Cancer?

Ask a Doctor Online

* guaranteed answer within 4 hours.
Enter Your Health Query
You can upload files and images in the next step.

Fee:  

 


Disclaimer: All health articles published on this website is not intended to be a substitute for professional medical diagnosis, advice or treatment by a trained physician. Seek the advice from your physician or other qualified health-care providers with questions you may have regarding your symptoms and medical condition for a complete medical diagnosis. Do not delay or disregard seeking professional medical advice because of something you have read on this website.